A personal reflection on the October 7 anniversary: remembering the victims, honouring their humanity and refusing to normalise the atrocities or their celebration.
I will never be the same either. Mostly because of the sick, sadistic things that were done to those precious Israelis (and their guests), but also because of the sick, sadistic reaction around the world- including American college campuses. What an absolute horror. People died. Decency died. And a sense of safety died for all Jews around the world. My own friend and neighbor’s reaction was “well, there are issues on both sides”. I’ll never forget it. And I’ll never forgive it. Am Yisrael Chai.
History rhymes. Jews cannot afford or allow it: “Hard times create strong men. Strong men create good times. Good times create weak men. And, weak men create hard times.”
How readily the world washes its hands in Jewish blood. Three sins produce this outcome.
First is the Sin of Commission. It is performed by those who willlfully and joyfully persecute Jews.
The second is the Sin of Omission. It is committed by those who stand by and do nothing while evil does its dirty work.
The third is the Sin of Indifference. It may be the worst of the three sins because like its sister, the Sin of Omission, it may claim its hands are clean. Not so! It is morally complicit. Its turning a blind eye gives license to Omission and Commission.
To the Sin of Commission it says there will be no hand to stop you nor any consequences. Emboldened, the Sin of Commission feels free to inflict even greater violence.
To the Sin of Omission, it says your inaction is reasonable. Why try to protect those with whom you have nothing to do.
Omission and Indifference may cry that they are innocent. They might declare that they have nothing to do with Jewish suffering. But if asked what Jews did to deserve it, their answer is "Because they are Jews. Go read their history."
I will never be the same either. Mostly because of the sick, sadistic things that were done to those precious Israelis (and their guests), but also because of the sick, sadistic reaction around the world- including American college campuses. What an absolute horror. People died. Decency died. And a sense of safety died for all Jews around the world. My own friend and neighbor’s reaction was “well, there are issues on both sides”. I’ll never forget it. And I’ll never forgive it. Am Yisrael Chai.
Thank-you, Yonatan.
History rhymes. Jews cannot afford or allow it: “Hard times create strong men. Strong men create good times. Good times create weak men. And, weak men create hard times.”
G. Michael Hopf, Those Who Remain
How readily the world washes its hands in Jewish blood. Three sins produce this outcome.
First is the Sin of Commission. It is performed by those who willlfully and joyfully persecute Jews.
The second is the Sin of Omission. It is committed by those who stand by and do nothing while evil does its dirty work.
The third is the Sin of Indifference. It may be the worst of the three sins because like its sister, the Sin of Omission, it may claim its hands are clean. Not so! It is morally complicit. Its turning a blind eye gives license to Omission and Commission.
To the Sin of Commission it says there will be no hand to stop you nor any consequences. Emboldened, the Sin of Commission feels free to inflict even greater violence.
To the Sin of Omission, it says your inaction is reasonable. Why try to protect those with whom you have nothing to do.
Omission and Indifference may cry that they are innocent. They might declare that they have nothing to do with Jewish suffering. But if asked what Jews did to deserve it, their answer is "Because they are Jews. Go read their history."
https://music.apple.com/us/album/freedom-song-zahor-9-11/53431692?i=53431569