Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Infidel753's avatar

Fascinating ideas, and thank you for sticking your neck out and expressing them. Medieval religious architecture (Islamic as well as Christian) does have an oppressive quality to it, even if it's also ornate in ways that would have stood out as appealing in the relatively dull general environment of medieval cities. And there's no denying that the great cathedrals and palaces were built partly as assertions of power by the mighty over ordinary individuals.

If American monumental architectures is much more obviously ugly, well, it's the same kind of assertion of power by the mighty, except it's corporate power rather than religious, while most of the aesthetic sense of ornateness from the Middle Ages has been lost.

Expand full comment
man of aran's avatar

"they were constructed to humble man, not glorify him" Yes, exactly. But your overall critique, to me, is ahistorical. Your assumption that a piece of architecture *should* glorify man would strike any medieval cathedral builder or European citizen of the time as blasphemy. They wouldn't even understand it. Because you've omitted God from the equation. It was not about 'humbling' man in the sense of subjugation, it was about glorifying God through architectural design, the spires, the ceilings and floor plans, the light through stained glass etc. to show man his 'humble' place in the order of things but at the same time lift his spirit closer to the Divine. Properly understood, cathedrals as places of worship were a person could find liberation from his fallen humanness, his sin, not enslavement. This was exactly the moral purpose that a cathedral was intended to express and serve. You might not agree with that, but I think you need to acknowledge the truth of it in an historical context.

Of course, that doesn't make every cathedral automatically beautiful, some were obviously more successful in achieving their vision than others.

I do agree with your mission, here, though, to recover a sense of beauty in the world as it's true that the modern age has for more than a century now essentially turned against the whole idea. And the connection with moral purpose is definitely important. To glorify man? Maybe, but personally, I think that effort has brought us to some pretty dark places.

Expand full comment
10 more comments...

No posts